The Non-Solicitation Clause Toolkit for Trainer Agreements: Drafting, Scope and Enforcement in Malaysia
· By Ayda Editorial

The morning a client becomes your trainer's client
A provider in Petaling Jaya runs a two-day supervisory skills programme for a manufacturing client in Shah Alam. The trainer is a freelancer on a per-day rate. Six months later, the client's HR manager calls the trainer directly to book the same course for a second plant. Nobody tells the provider. There is no dispute, no dramatic exit — just a quiet shift of a relationship the provider spent two years and several unpaid proposal rounds building.
Most Malaysian training providers already have a non-solicitation clause somewhere in their freelance trainer agreement. The problem is rarely the absence of a clause. It is that the clause is either so broad that it is unlikely to survive scrutiny, or so vague that it cannot be evidenced when something goes wrong. This toolkit walks through the drafting decisions, the scope questions, and the records that make a clause usable rather than decorative.
Start with who the clause protects
Draft short and defensible: courts will not rewrite an over-broad covenant for you.
Before drafting a single line, decide which of three interests you are protecting. They need different language.
- The provider's client relationship. The clause stops a trainer from approaching your client to book training directly during and shortly after the engagement.
- The provider's pipeline and proposals. The clause covers the specific accounts you introduced, not the trainer's entire market.
- The client's own interest. Some corporate clients ask providers to ensure trainers do not market competing programmes to their staff. This belongs in the client contract, not the trainer contract, and needs a different mechanism.
A clause that tries to cover all three at once usually ends up covering none of them cleanly. Pick the primary interest, draft for it, and add the others as narrow secondary provisions.
Solicitation versus an inbound referral
The distinction most trainer agreements miss: a trainer who emails your client's L&D manager with a new course outline is soliciting. A trainer who receives a call because the client found their LinkedIn profile and wants to book them is not — or at least, not in the same way. Malaysian courts are wary of restraint-of-trade covenants, and a clause that treats every inbound enquiry as a breach reads as a restraint on the trainer's ability to earn a living.
A workable clause therefore separates the two:
- Prohibited: the trainer initiates contact with a named client, or with anyone the provider introduced, for the purpose of supplying training services directly or through another provider.
- Permitted: the trainer responds to a documented inbound request, provided they notify the provider in writing within a set window (seven days is common) and offer the provider the right to quote first.
- Outside scope: clients the trainer was already working with before the engagement, and clients who appear on the trainer's own prior-client list disclosed at signing.
That second category is the one that saves you in a real dispute. Without it, your clause looks punitive; with it, you have a fair process that a court or an arbitrator can follow.
What Malaysian law says about restraint of trade
Section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950 provides that agreements in restraint of trade are void, subject to the exceptions set out in that section. Malaysian commentary on the provision is clear that once a covenant falls within restraint of trade, the court has no discretion to remake it — it is void, subject to those exceptions. Commentary also notes that the English-style reasonableness test is not the operative test under section 28, and that the section is generally understood to bite in the post-contract period rather than during the currency of the contract.
Separately, Malaysian employment commentary observes that post-employment covenants restricting an employee from competing are treated cautiously, and that contractual rights may be waived for consideration where statutory rights ordinarily cannot.
Translate that into practical drafting consequences for a trainer agreement:
- Keep the covenant narrow. A restraint on a trainer's whole profession, across all of Malaysia, for three years is exactly the kind of term that invites a void finding.
- Anchor it to something you own. The client relationship you introduced is a protectable commercial interest in a way that "all training in Selangor" is not.
- Separate during-contract obligations from post-contract ones. Exclusivity and non-solicitation while the trainer is engaged under your contract sit on much firmer ground than a post-termination restriction.
- Do not assume a court will fix your wording. Drafting short and defensible beats drafting long and hoping for a saving construction.
This is general commentary, not legal advice. Have a Malaysian lawyer review your template before you roll it out, especially if you are amending existing agreements with trainers who are mid-programme.
The over-broad clause, and a shorter alternative
Here is the kind of wording that shows up in templates copied from overseas employment contracts:
"The Trainer shall not, for a period of three (3) years following termination, directly or indirectly engage in, provide, promote or be associated with any training, consultancy or coaching services to any person or entity within Malaysia, nor solicit or accept business from any client of the Provider."
Three years, the whole country, every service line, plus a cap on accepting business — that is a restraint on carrying on a trade, and it is the sort of clause most likely to be attacked as void rather than enforced.
A shorter alternative, tied to what you actually introduced:
"During the Engagement and for twelve (12) months after it ends, the Trainer shall not initiate contact with any Client introduced by the Provider for the purpose of supplying training services directly or through another provider. This does not restrict the Trainer from (a) responding to an unsolicited written request from such a Client, provided the Trainer notifies the Provider in writing within seven (7) days and gives the Provider a first right to quote; (b) working with clients listed in Schedule A; or (c) accepting work through a client's own approved vendor panel. 'Client introduced by the Provider' means a client the Provider first engaged, booked or quoted for during the twelve (12) months before the Engagement started, as recorded in Schedule B."
The second version is shorter, narrower, and — crucially — it defines its own trigger. If you cannot point to a Schedule B entry showing you introduced the client, you have no case, and you should know that before you sign rather than after.
Setting duration and geography you can defend
Duration and geography are where optimism creeps in. A rough guide for a Malaysian freelance trainer agreement:
| Element | Aggressive | Defensible starting point |
|---|---|---|
| Post-engagement duration | 24–36 months | 6–12 months for per-day freelance trainers |
| Geography | Nationwide | The client's operating locations you actually serve |
| Scope of activity | All training and consultancy | The programme or subject area you booked them for |
| Trigger | Any contact | Trainer-initiated contact for direct supply |
Tie duration to relationship value. If you spent six months and multiple proposal revisions to win a client, a twelve-month window is easier to justify than if you booked the trainer for a single one-day session. That is also why it is worth knowing your real cost per proposal — the training provider admin cost breakdown helps you argue that a client relationship represents real investment, not just a booking.
Geography is usually the weakest part of Malaysian templates. If your client operates in Johor and Penang only, a nationwide clause is hard to tie to any legitimate interest. Name the states, or name the client's site list.
Carve-outs that keep the clause fair and usable
Include these explicitly. Each one reduces the chance a tribunal reads your clause as an unreasonable restraint.
- Prior clients. A schedule listing client names the trainer worked with before signing.
- Vendor panels. Some corporate clients require trainers to be on their approved vendor panel. A clause that forbids a trainer from accepting panel work can cause the client real operational problems and makes you look unreasonable.
- Inbound referrals from other trainers. If another trainer refers work to them, that is not your client relationship.
- Public courses and open enrolment. A trainer running a public workshop in a hotel is not soliciting your client's staff individually. Say so.
- Substitution and continuity. If a trainer must be replaced mid-programme, the incoming trainer needs to be able to speak to the client. Deal with this in the same agreement — our freelance trainer substitution post-mortem shows how quickly a badly handled handover damages client trust.
The record-keeping that proves solicitation
A clause you cannot evidence is a clause you cannot use. If a dispute reaches a lawyer, the first question will be: what actually happened, and in what order? Build the file as a matter of routine.
- Proposal and quotation trail. Every version, timestamped, with the client contact named. This establishes that you introduced the relationship.
- Booking emails and confirmations. Who booked whom, for which programme, at which site.
- Attendance sheets and certificates. These show which client staff were in the room and when — useful both for the programme record and for showing where the relationship originated.
- The trainer's Schedule A and Schedule B. Signed at onboarding, not added later.
- A dated log of any inbound-request notification from the trainer. A seven-day notice is only meaningful if you can show the date it arrived.
- Client-side evidence. A short email from the client confirming when they were first approached is far stronger than a reconstruction two years later.
Most of this is the same documentation you already produce for HRD Corp programme records. If your quotations, invoices and certificates are generated consistently from one system, the evidence trail exists by default. That consistency is part of why providers consolidate document generation — see how corporate training proposal template practices overlap with claim-ready paperwork.
Roles and who owns each step
A clause only works if someone in your business actually runs it. In a typical small provider, that breaks down like this:
| Role | Owns |
|---|---|
| Owner / director | Approves clause wording, signs off Schedule A and B, decides whether to enforce |
| Programme manager | Maintains the client-introduction log, flags new bookings against the schedule |
| Admin executive | Files proposals, booking emails and attendance sheets per client, keeps them retrievable |
| Finance | Checks whether invoices to a disputed client were issued by the provider or another entity |
| External counsel | Reviews template, drafts any letter of demand, assesses enforceability |
On cost: a Malaysian lawyer reviewing a fixed trainer agreement template is typically a one-off fee rather than a per-trainer cost, and it is small next to the value of one retained corporate client. Compare it to the course pricing training provider malaysia models — a single mid-sized in-house programme usually dwarfs the legal review fee. If you are booking enough freelancers that clause administration is becoming a chore, that is a signal your operations need structure, which is the same question raised in scale training provider operations.
Where HRD Corp scheme context fits in
A trainer's accreditation status is not a contractual lever, and it does not affect whether a non-solicitation clause is enforceable. What it does affect is how attractive that trainer is to your client — which is exactly why the relationship is worth protecting.
Keep the two tracks separate:
- Accreditation and trainer standing. Trainers holding a TTT Certificate of Completion or TTT Exemption obtained after 1 January 2021 must undergo HRD Corp Accreditation through an assessment process within 6 months from the date of TTT course completion or exemption. If you are contracting trainers for claimable programmes, verify where each trainer is in that process, and confirm current requirements on the official HRD Corp portal rather than relying on a template clause. Our trainer sourcing hr d corp scorecard covers the verification sequence.
- Your provider registration. Your status as a registered provider is a separate matter from any individual trainer's agreement, and it is worth re-reading the hrd corp training provider registration walkthrough if you are expanding the panel.
Do not write a clause that ties a trainer's accreditation status to a penalty under the non-solicitation covenant. That mixes two unrelated obligations and makes the whole clause look confused.
A practical sequence for the next week
- Pull every current freelance trainer agreement and highlight the non-solicitation wording.
- Count how many name a duration, a geography, and a defined trigger. Most will fail on at least one.
- Draft a one-page replacement clause using the short version above as a starting point.
- Build Schedule A (the trainer's prior clients) and Schedule B (clients you introduced) for each active trainer.
- Send the template to a Malaysian lawyer for review.
- Re-paper at renewal rather than mid-programme, where possible, to avoid disrupting delivery.
- Set a monthly check that new bookings are logged against Schedule B, so the record exists before you need it.
What good looks like a year later
The measure of a non-solicitation clause is not how many disputes you win. It is whether the awkward conversation never has to happen, because both sides understood the boundary from day one. A trainer who knows exactly which clients are yours, and exactly how to handle an inbound request, is a trainer who stays on your panel for years.
That is the outcome worth aiming for: a clause short enough to defend, specific enough to explain, and backed by records you already keep.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a non-solicitation clause enforceable in Malaysia?
It depends on how it is drafted. Section 28 of the Contracts Act 1950 makes agreements in restraint of trade void subject to the exceptions in that section, and Malaysian commentary notes that the court has no discretion to remake a covenant once it falls within restraint of trade. Clauses scoped to a defined client relationship, with a modest duration and a clear trigger, are easier to support than nationwide, multi-year restraints. Get a Malaysian lawyer to review your specific template.
How long should a trainer non-solicitation clause last?
There is no fixed statutory period. As a starting point for per-day freelance trainers, six to twelve months after the engagement ends is far easier to justify than two to three years, particularly where you can show the client relationship required real investment. Longer periods may be arguable for trainers embedded in a multi-year programme, but expect scrutiny.
Does the clause stop a client from approaching my trainer directly?
No. A non-solicitation clause binds the trainer, not the client. If a client chooses to approach a trainer directly, your protection comes from the client relationship itself — the contract with the client, the programme records, and the value you deliver. Some providers add a separate clause in the client agreement, which is a different document with different enforceability questions.
Can a trainer still respond to an inbound enquiry from my client?
Most workable clauses allow it, provided the trainer notifies you in writing within a set window and gives you a first right to quote. Treating every inbound contact as a breach makes the clause look like a restraint on the trainer's ability to earn a living, which weakens your position if it is ever tested.
What records do I need to prove solicitation?
At minimum: timestamped proposal and quotation versions naming the client contact, booking emails and confirmations, attendance sheets and certificates, the trainer's signed client schedules, and a dated log of any inbound-request notifications. A short confirming email from the client about when they were first approached is the strongest single piece of evidence.
Does HRD Corp accreditation affect my trainer agreement clause?
No. Accreditation requirements and contractual non-solicitation obligations are separate matters. Trainers who obtained a TTT Certificate of Completion or TTT Exemption after 1 January 2021 must undergo HRD Corp Accreditation through an assessment process within 6 months from the date of TTT course completion or exemption, but that has no bearing on whether a non-solicitation clause is enforceable. Confirm current requirements on the official HRD Corp portal.